I purchased my AppleTV in February of 2007 and I use it regularly for listening to music, watching movies and video podcasts. I love the simplicity of Apple products so I’ll admit some bias here. Setting that aside, Apple has made a lot or progress with the giants in the movie and TV industry to support the idea of renting movies online and the online movie industry has come a long way in 12 months with more content and of course more competition.
I would like to start by providing some perspective regarding our home setup and viewing habits. No cable TV, no satellite TV – cable is only used for Internet access. I found cable TV to be an expensive option that provided shows we did not want to watch with limited HD (though that’s been changing) and way too many commercials. I do not want to spend the few hours I have for TV and movie watching waiting and hoping one of those 200 channels might play what I want. So we use a TV antenna for local channels and it works out perfectly for what we want. TivoHD is used to record for when we want to record and view later. Local broadcasters now have everything in HD and the image quality (to my eyes) appears as sharp as a Blu-Ray.
Unfortunately, the idea of ala carte access to cable TV (or satellite TV) channels continue to fall on deaf ears, so I’ve given up that wish. And in walks Apple who provided my first entry into watching what I wanted whenever I wanted without paying monthly fees for the privileges that I rarely used. For me the big win with AppleTV was that personal satisfaction of finding a movie I hadn’t seen before (or in a long time) and watching it ‘right’ when I’m ready to do so with no commercials and no on-going fees and most of all, no hassle in returning the movie.
With AppleTV (as with Netflix streaming and VUDU) you don’t have figure out what you want to watch in advance. You don’t have to haul yourself to a local Blockbuster only to find out the DVD movie you want is out or they don’t carry it. And if you’re like me, you always manage to get home from BlockBuster (or get mailed from Netflix) that one DVD that someone else has dragged across the kitchen counter or some other fate that leaves it unreadable. What a big buzz kill for a Friday night movie session at home!
There is one major drawback to only seeing movies online right now – NO special features. Sigh … i so miss them.
Ok, now for more on AppleTV. Remember these are my impressions. I’m not promising this is the most comprehensive list of capabilities (or wishes for new capabilities). If you’ve got something to say just add it into the comments. I’m game and I’ll update these posts where appropriate.
How You Order One:
You have to purchase from Apple directly or an authorized Apple dealer. There are two models, different only by size of disk drive – 40GB and 160GB. Visit Apple for more details, but keep in mind that you can shop around for a discounted price. Basically you can walk into BestBuy or any other Apple dealer to get one. Don’t forget to pick up the necessary cables which are not packaged with the AppleTV. The best buy for HDMI cables is NOT BestBuy, my favorite place is www.showmecables.com.
Of the three boxes, AppleTV is the only one you can readily experience before you buy. Recommend you drop by an Apple store and get a salesperson to give you the remote and play with their setup. Netflix does not currently authorize any retail outlets to carry the Roku box. You ‘could’ see the Netflix movie watching ability on some of the newer LG DVD players that include the capability (very recent) or if you know someone that has a TivoHD, you can see Netflix in action there. Currently, the Vudu store locator finds no stores near me in Austin, so you will probably have to order online. More on all this in the following reviews.
Purchase Price:
Retail – $229 (40GB) and $329 (160GB). No rental fees. So far, no upgrade fees over the last year of occasional upgrades.
I own the 40GB version. One of the benefits of using iTunes on Mac or PC is you can keep more movies and music on a desktop PC (or even a laptop) and share your movies and music over your local network with the AppleTV. So it’s not absolutely critical you have the larger drive as long as you have a desktop or laptop on your network and it’s up and running.
What you Get:
The AppleTV box has a microprocessor, memory and hard drive but no display. You can get all the technical specifications here for the box. You have to connect it to your TV via an HDMI cable or RGB cables. And you will want to hook the unit up to the Internet via your home wifi (or wired network connection is my preference) to access movie rentals to download from the Internet. The box runs pretty darn hot so you’ll want to give it a bit of breathing room when setting up. I suggest turning it off when not in use.
First Impressions:
From the moment you open the AppleTV box to when you plug in and boot up, the AppleTV is first class all the way. And that’s exactly what you’d expect. Admittedly, I was enamored with the box last year because it did so much of what I’d been wanting for a long time – quality movie rentals at a reasonable price along with the added bonus of the ability to play my music collection and view my family picture collection. And now, more and more, AppleTV offers movies and TV shows in HD.
The first time you hook the AppleTV up to your iTunes (PC or Apple) you have to enter a code in so both devices are aware of each other. It’s not hard; it’s just a new step for most folks. The instructions are very clear as to how it’s done so I’m not going to go through all that. I just remember having to help folks do that over the phone over the last year. It’s not critical you hook the AppleTV to your iTunes but it sure is worth the effort.
If you have iTunes on a PC or Apple computer you can synchronize all the pictures you want to see on your TV: music and playlists, audio and video podcasts, movies and TV shows. The Apple iTunes library for music is huge as we all know and the selection of movies is expanding rapidly. You can also convert existing movies to AppleTV, but you’ll need additional software if you’re into that. A weekly updated list of Apple downloads (for purchase or rental) is available.
The most unexpected excitement from the AppleTV box was the instant access to movie trailers that are about to be released. In our house, we’ve been known to sit in the theater room about once a month and comb through all the new movie trailers and just make an evening of it. What a HUGE missed opportunity on Apple’s part, by not offering some way to select movies to be notified about when released for purchase and/or rental. I’d be delighted.
The unit is small and easy to transport. I’ve taken it over to my girlfriend’s apartment to use with her Sony LCD TV. I only needed an HDMI cable and a network cable. I could have even gone wireless without the network cable, but I did not want to mess with typing in the security code.
All in all, the box covers a lot of ground for what I want to do at home and it leverages what I have in place for home entertainment. Viewing and storing family pictures, watching and listening to podcasts from the iTunes library and listening to my extensive music collection: all make the AppleTV a wonderful addition to my theater room. I can listen to music in the background during parties, while cooking and so forth. I really enjoy watching the family photos float by in the screen saver mood. Or I can just turn the LCD projector off and let my playlists work its way through music that is a good match for the mood of the evening. Now if you’re new to podcast then you owe it to yourself to explore that area in iTunes. Most of the audio and video podcasts are free and there is a rich selection of topics.
Renting and Buying Movies and TV Shows:


The process of renting a movie is simple. You scroll around the movie artwork and find one you’re interested in. Watch a preview and then select your rental option – SD (standard definition) is called RENT. Currently charges range from $0.99 ( specials) to $3.99. Though I find SD rentals look quite good, my eyes have grown accustomed to the higher resolution of HD. Most of the newer movies released are HD and the price usually varies from $3.99 to $4.99. You will notice many of the older movies in their library are not available in HD ( also issue for Netflix and VUDU).
If you have a fast Internet connection (say 2MB/sec or more preferably) then movies will start playing within a minute or two. AppleTV lets you know when it’s time to start playing the movie. You can watch while it downloads the remaining part of the movie in the background. It’s all quite seamless. Frankly, it’s remarkable to have an HD movie start playing just 1-2 minutes after you start it up.
What you get for the price you pay – renting means you have 30 days to watch the movie. But once you hit play, the movie activates with Apple servers and the clock starts ticking. When that happens, you have 24 hours to complete your viewing of the movie. There is no option of extending the move rental (VUDU does btw) which at times would be nice but not a show stopper.
Purchasing is just as simple as renting and basically the same process except you get to download it and keep it forever (storage space needed, of course). Movies are typically priced at $14.99. AppleTV also has quite a rich selection of TV shows you can purchase. No renting available here. Wish you could. TV shows are generally $.99 and discounts are available if you buy an entire set of episodes for a given year. We’ve done this at home, but it’s just not very price effective. We watch them once and that’s it. I did the math and it was cheaper to rent from BlockBuster, especially if we are just trying to get totally caught up on a TV show with multiple years of episodes. However, for an occasional gotta see now, AppleTV provides instant gratification and many of the TV shows are in HD. They look beautiful.
A small aside about HD. HD is high definition meaing 1280x 720 (horizontal and vertical vertical resolution for each frame of the movie). However AppleTV is not true native HD. It would need to be 1920×1080 which is only available from VUDU online (or Blu-Ray DVDs). Keep in mind that true HD (1920×1080) is just not practical to stream and the file size for downloading is huge – taking hours. We’ll get more into this when we talk about the VUDU system that provides an answer here (along with their tradeoffs). The question is can you live without that extra resolution? You’ll find in my next review of the Netflix Roku box that their movie choice very week when it comes to finding HD selections and their SD and HD movies still lack a little something to me in the image quality and depth or feel of the movie. I can’t quite put my finger on it. However Netflix does have the widest selection of movies from all genres online. So, like all things in life, there are tradeoffs. I’ll discuss this more with Netflix and VUDU. Each has their own approach that is different than what you get with AppleTV.
One final note on the selection of movies, most new movies are showing up on all three platforms these days. Note I said ‘most’. And when you start getting the hankering to see older movies you’ve missed, this is where it gets dicey trying to find which vendor has it (or doesn’t have it). I’ll close with my impression that Apple’s HD (and frankly most of the SD ) movies ‘look’ awesome. Eventually your first choice becomes HD (not always offered) over time as your eyes get accustomed to the fine smooth grain nature of HD resolution. Apple’s 720 HD is perfectly acceptable in my theater room and obviously looks great on a 40″ LCD TV. Generally Apple HD movies also have 5.1 audio and adds one more enjoyable dimension to the experience of watching a movie.
What I like About AppleTV:
In short I like the the ability to add in my own music, my own movies and download podcasts. But most of all there is just something about the way AppleTV displays movies with such clarity. Even if I rent a standard definition movie (given it’s fairly recent (say in the last 10 years), that SD movie will still be beautiful to watch on my 92″ theater screen. It’s not HD but somehow these movies are easy on the eyes even with upscaling to fill the screen. The Sony LCD projector upscales it and it almost look like HD and of course on a 40″ LCD or Plasma TV it will look remarkable. AppleTV does a remarkable job of making media look and sound good. And using the AppleTV with that little remote is smooth and easy. You can’t go wrong owning one and you can likely pick one up on Criagslist now. I’m not saying it’s for everyone but there is a lot to like about it especially if you’re into seeing your own images, movies and music on your TV or in your theater room.
Other things you can do on AppleTV is view YouTube videos. It’s not something I spend time doing but the kids like it. You can also interface your collection of images on FLICKR and MobileME but that’s not something I do either.
One particular note is AppleTV provides a preview of everything for sale or rent, no exceptions. The Netflix interface allows this if you drag a laptop into the living room (or theater room) and bring up their website. VUDU provides previews of their movies and TV shows for rent or purchase, BUT for some reason I find an annoying number of things do not show the preview button. It never occurred to me you would NOT be able to preview what you’re about to rent or buy online so it’s a mystery to my why VUDU is not as complete as AppleTV. Maybe I’ll have more answers on that with the VUDU review in few days.
What I Wish was Different:
I’d like to see a wider movie selection. Seems like they are putting more online but to me many of the AppleTV choices seem to be ‘politically correct’ versus Netflix where you can find just about anything you want with regards to movies and TV shows. But when it bcomes to viewing a movie (especially one released in the last 5 years), it is in HD and 5.1 audio and I’m going to pay for the movie on AppleTV before the other two options of Netflix and Vudu. Yes, VUDU provides similar quality (even better in some cases) but they are also about a $5 more. We’ll get to VUDU in a few days.
The point is none of the boxes provide the answer to all my wishes or likely yours. Sometimes I just want to watch something off the beaten path like a Tony Bennett documentary that is only available on Netflix but where the quality is only acceptable and not nearly as pristine and sharp as it would be on AppleTV (or Vudu). But that is what I wanted to watch so I was willing to be less picky about image quality and just let myself be entertained. But I digress…
My biggest gripe is the same one I have with all three vendors. I want the option to see special features that comes with most DVD rentals. You don’t get that with movie streaming (nothing, nada, never). And you can’t even get anyone to tell you why or when or why not. Doesn’t seem like a programming issue. I’m guessing it’s all part of the complexities that come with licensing movies for online view.
The other wish/gripe is to see movies immediately when they are released to the movie houses. I’m guessing it would mean paying a higher price for the first month or two and then it would drop back. But so what. Have you been the movies in a while? For two people it can be nearly $30 by the time you pay for a drink and popcorn. I’d gladly pay a higher rental fee to see a first run movie say a week after it’s released. But again, I’m sure there are very difficult licensing arrangements for the existing infrastructure of movie houses. And of course the ongoing fear of making movies to easy for folks to pirate. Sigh … all of this in time will change I assume. It’s only been a year since AppleTV was released and we could so easily rent movies.
As the competition heats up in 2009 for online movie (and TV) watching, I hope AppleTV keeps up with the crowd by providing more content from different sources. There is a company called BOXEE that is doing some amazing things with AppleTV, if you’re interested in loading their code on your box. It doesn’t hurt to do that but it’s a bit of a hassle to sort out exactly how to install it. I have multiple friends that gave it a try and gave up. If you’re in the Austin area and you have BOXEE running let me know. I’ll offer up a free meal for helping me to get it going as part of this test.
Finally, my biggest gripe with AppleTV has to do with quality of service. For some reason, ever since the November 2008 time frame (it’s now early February 2009), myself and others in Austin have been experiencing problems with movie trailers and movie downloads being slow VERY slow; often having to stop and restart. It can be a huge buzz kill on a Friday night when all you want to do is start watching a movie. This has happened multiple times to me, to my girl friend at her place and to others located around town. I know it’s not a network issue, because when those interruptions of service occur I try streaming a movie from Netflix or VUDU and they ‘always’ work with no problems. So, Apple – get on this issue!
My biggest wish is the ability to tag movie trailers on AppleTV so I’m notified when they hit the theaters or better yet when Apple gets them for rental. This would definitely encourage greater use of my AppleTV (or any of the boxes really). User interface with vendors is sadly lacking. Netflix does offer the ability to tag movies long before they are released, but you are not notified when they become available for viewing.
Ending:
I love my AppleTV. I’m hoping and feeling a bit worried AppleTV isn’t a front a center product for Apple so upgrades and improvements might not be forthcoming. But they are continuing to add a lot of new movies each week, so for now I’ll continue using it provided the networking/quality of service issue is resolved. More and more I find myself using Netflix and Vudu for instant watching gratification due to AppleTV’s speed of download issues.
Next up – Netflix
Tom
Contact Tom
About Tom
Google Reader Shared Items
- For Women, Social Media is More Than “Girl Talk” (Mashable!)
- Top 5 Open Innovation Companies – July (15inno)
- Mad Men - The Carousel (Higher Quality) (talkingportraits's YouTube Activity)
- Mad Men - The Carousel (Higher Quality) (talkingportraits's YouTube Activity)
- Why I Turned In My iPhone and Went Android (louisgray.com)
Shared ItemsPages
Home